Search This Blog

Loading...

Monday, September 5, 2011

Where do I belong?



This post has been awarded the 'Tejaswee Rao Blogging Awards 2011'. Thank you friends for your support.

Like every other week day, I boarded my bus at 8.40 am and was glad to find an empty seat in the ladies section. I slid in thankfully in an empty ladies seat and stared out at the same roads that were a part of my everyday. Two stops away from where I boarded, the bus stopped for a minute to pick up four passengers. Like everyone else, my eyes gazed in idle curiosity at the new entrants. Just as I was about to take away my eyes from idle speculation I noticed that one of them was a transgender. My gaze paused there for a wee bit more than on the others. Idly I watched as the person made their way to a seat near the ladies section. There was space yet for a moderately thin person to fit in. To my surprise the lady sitting there, immediately shifted herself, covering the entire expanse of the seat and politely gestured the transgender towards the male section. When the said person moved towards the male section, the bus conductor shouted, “You are supposed to be seated in the ladies section” There was something about the look on the face of the transgender that day that I would not forget in a long time.

Back home from office, the face haunted me. What would it be to belong nowhere? The feeling that you are neither here nor there..actually nowhere perhaps. I had of course seen transgender s many a times in life, like most of us do and given them curious looks and passed away, without giving it much of a thought. But that day, something touched deep inside me. I wondered how these people would feel in a society that did not accept them as a part of its normalcy. Like the scene I had seen on the bus, most people don’t know where to place transgender s.

The biggest problem is that faced by parents of the transgender s. While many still think it is a curse to have a child like that, others at times resort to violence. Plenty of transgender s face the problem of having parents who cannot accept them and as a result try to cure them by either beating, scolding or using other methods which they think would cure their child of the disease. As a result most often these children are forced to leave home unless of course the parents themselves throw the children out of their homes. In such cases the child is left to fend for itself. It is only when one is thrown outside into the wide world that one knows how cruel people can be. Transgender s are not acceptable in any jobs, neither are they granted educational rights. Many a times, the excuse of not employing them is as flimsy as not being able to bear the burden of seeing a so called abnormal person in their midst, day after day! This practically leaves most members of this community with only one option- that of prostitution. But matters don’t end here, the same job that the transgender is forced to do is again one of the strongest reasons why every time you see a transgender in any public place, the police will be out questioning them on the reason for hanging around in that particular area.

I wondered if people have any idea about the kind of trauma a person would go through if the society one lives in does not consider them normal and ill treats them for no fault of their own! Strangely enough, people find it easier to accept homosexual and lesbians but are strangely uncomfortable when it comes to transgender s.

There are many people who have over the years developed an instinctive irritation/hatred for these people. When yours truly asked a few people the reason why they disliked such people, the reasons varied from an amused- “because they are odd and I’m not comfortable in their presence” to “They are a nuisance on the roads, begging for money all the time” I wonder how many people realize that no community would want to beg, if they could have had a decent way of living, in every community there is good, there is bad and there is honor too.

It is time that the so called NORMAL people realize, these are also children of God and treating them right is our duty and their birthright.

‘A Transgender is a person, who identifies with or expresses a gender identity that differs from the one which corresponds to the person’s sex at the time of birth’

http://thesipoflife.com/2011/08/tune-in-to-priyanka-90-4-radio-active/
My interview of Priyanka R, a transgender radio jockey for community radio 90.4 for 'The sip of life'

33 comments:

chitra said...

ooh...attimes i might have starred at transgender s, for nw i realise they hav made no sin to be so...and y the hell we see them that way !!!
this is a worth post to read today.

Maitreyee Bhattacharjee Chowdhury said...

Thank you Chitra, Im glad someone understood this sensitive issue. Regards

Hariharan Valady said...

How embarrassing it would have been for the person in the bus! Again being ignored by one's parents...Quite painful. I have never thought seriously about these issues. In fact I used to get irritated with them when I see them in trains. This has post has made a definite impact on me.

Chintan said...

:( i feel sad when i spot transgenders...life can be cruel...

Ashwini said...

True. They are treated badly.They should be looked upon as fellow human beings, with feelings and emotions just like us.
I remember reading this.
Lord Shiva and Parvathi came together as Ardhanarishwarar. Half male. Half Female. So Transgenders,are supposed to be considered God like and divine. Hurts to see the way they are treated.

Priyanka Kamath said...

I have always been weirdly scared of transgenders. If it is their way of communicating that got me to be frightened or the way they dress up, is hard to decide. I would grab onto the hand of the person sitting next to me in an auto rickshaw when I'd see a transgender walking towards me. I never ill treated them though. However, after reading this, I know I will warmly smile when I happen to come across a transgender:)
They are humans who deserve to be treated well by the creatures around who call themselves humans.

merrymusing said...

Liked you post...made a wonderful change to read about a community that I see everyday, and always get startled when they creep up on me when I am seated in an auto, asking for money.
I always used to wonder - "Why don't they do some work? After all they looked perfectly healthy."
But now I realise the social stigma attached to them, and how no one would want to employ them.

VINOD ARORA said...

Everyone should be careful and concerned for them as well...its perfectly acceptable. I appreciate your way of expression !!

ashwini said...

Normal is boring! Its a vicious circle. We push them to be the way they are in India and then mock them or are scared of them when they approach us. They too should be allowed normal professions so that the stigma of the 'dancing and begging'transgender in India, will go away.

Maitreyee Bhattacharjee Chowdhury said...

I would like to thank all of you for having read or commented here and more importantly felt about their plight. It is time I believe that as progressive people we see that these are normal people and treat them as such.

Deguide said...

I am strongly in favour of reservation for such people in all types of jobs without exception. Railways, Police etc would be ideal place for them to be employed. Good post

Neeraj Kumar said...

Deep thoughts!

merC_ry said...

Actually this post made me think today. Just as when I was reading it I remembered many times when I have looked at them without an emotion, tried to vacate my mind of their presence.

Its something no one can understand how one must be feeling, though your article indeed comes close in portraying the plight of such ignored elements of society.

SUB said...

prejudice is our biggest problem...it's not a disease, they are just different...

but for some strange reason we feel uncomfortable when something 'different' happens...and a common way to react in such situation is to hurt the cause of that discomfort...

don't understand why the regular people are so insecure?

great post as always :)

S.R.Ayyangar said...

Its true that WE all refrain to talk about these people and just do not care to think of their plight. They are only known to use abusive language if not paid at traffic signals.Successive Governments have also done nothing to rehabilitate them with suitable status or job opportunity.

Barkha Dhar said...

Hail to pensive thoughts that are positive and thought provoking. I believe that it is the assumption of our normality that usually blurs our lens of seeing others who are different than us. It is interesting to note that you wrote quite candidly on this issue and then concluded by saying that we need to accept diversity in different forms even if it means accepting the transgenders as part of this world. That's such a wonderful thought!
Thanks for sharing your post and inspiring many to come out of an ignorant mindset.
Barkha Dhar
http://dharbarkha.blogspot.com/2011/06/from-stonewall-to-same-sex-marriages.html

ViJ@Y said...

Just stumbled on your blog.

Well try to read your blog regularly.

NNNiiiXXX said...

Beautiful... Thank u for bringing this up...

Sunil Deepak said...

Earlier this year, during our community research project in Karnataka on barriers faced by disabled persons, there was a meeting with some trans-gender persons. Their stories and the kind of challenges they face made a huge impact on the disabled persons who felt that trans-gender persons face tremendous barriers and need support and solidarity of the community.

Mohur said...

Things like this often make me wonder if we have actually 'developed' at all since the Stone Age.

We have such double standards!! We all like to claim that we are 'Unique' individuals, yet we are scared of the differences between us and transgenders/gays/lesbians. I have seen how scared/disgusted people feel of them. Something like this is unacceptable or unnatural and we immediately try to shun them away from the "Normal Society". But we never stop and think that they were born this way -- not something they had control over. Just like I couldn't help being born as a girl or born in India.

I read through your post and all the comments and I would like to say that - They do not need your pity or sympathy, because life and society has made them stronger. If you really feel for them, then just treat them like any other 'normal' people.

Mohur
http://mohur.blogspot.com

Maitreyee Bhattacharjee Chowdhury said...

Friends it makes me happy that there are many who feel their plight and many who through this post have felt like I did that there IS nothing wrong with them. Deguide, you would be interested in knowing that Bangalore university is the first in the entire country to have reservations for transgenders in higher studies. Thanks again friends for reading & taking up the issue with me.

ANSHUL GAUTAM said...

a very nice blog post. This is one of the most crucial aspect which often goes unnoticed. Even if we look out for them, we come out of it with nothing but carrying loads of hatred for them only. A feel of being different from normal of this form is very painful to bear.

www.anshul-gautam.blogspot.com/2011/09/college-fees.html

shveta said...

Maitreyee, u wrote so well, it's worth reading!
My personal experience is they are very nice people, if they treat us badly it's not because of their problem but actually we people are partial to them. You won't believe in my street there is a house in which 4-5 trans-genders live. Everybody in our locality talk to them, and in response they behave very nicely. Whenever there is a get-together like Mata Jagran, Marriage or child birth occasion, they participate decently. So I think it depends on us how we treat them and get the same from them.

KP said...

Ya.. how bad! people suffering for no mistake of theirs..! but ur post creates some awareness to those who read it.. hats off for that!

Maitreyee Bhattacharjee Chowdhury said...

Thanks everyone again..I hope this article ..at the least makes us THINK & give transgenders a fair chance at least to prove themselves..Mohur very well said..totally agree with you.

Abu said...

"Where do I belong?" in the context of present blog is a very pertinent question. And in general, another profound question that keeps bugging me "Who am I?"

We all struggle with these questions all our lives. But, I can imagine how hard it must have been for them! Even more difficult! They are one of us, they're no different! They may have some 'anatomical' differences, which coupled with peoples' reactions over a period of time, may have created some more differences in their minds! But they are as humans as we are!

I simply chose to ignore them when I encounter them in trains usually begging and exhorting money! I don't get angry because I know deep within its people like us who have brought more misery to their life! The least I can do is not despise them!

Things should change... some how... I don't know 'how' but I do wish they change... If we're talking of accepting same-sex marriages why are we so bias towards transgenders...

Well written blog Maitreyee, with profound thoughts!

Warm regards,

Maitreyee Bhattacharjee Chowdhury said...

Thanks Abu..lets keep our fingers crossed on that wish.

peter said...

I get irritated with them when I see them in trains and roads.

Like everywhere there are some good and some bad ones.

I dont like the way they used to beg in the streets and signals of hyderabd.

But i have a narrow soft corner for them

indianhomemaker said...

There's this beautiful Pakistani movie called 'Bol' that deals with this (along with many other issues)- awareness campaigns like this movie and your post, would eventually lead to transgender citizens being included in society like anybody else. But doesn't look like this is going to happen anytime soon.

Indian Home Maker said...

Congratulations :) This post in one of the winners of 'Tejaswee Rao Blogging Awards - 2011' (TRBA 2011). We would like to create an ebook with all the winning entries in 47 categories on Feminism and Gender Issues in India (and one category on Animals Rights). Please do let us know if you are fine with your winning post/s being included in this ebook. ( Please click here to let us know).

Mohur said...

Congrats!

Change said...

You said:

The biggest problem is that faced by parents of the transgender s.

I don't think so. Yes, parents/siblings/partners/etc of transgender children face a lot of problems. But the biggest problems are faced by transgender people themselves. To say that parents face the biggest hurdles is to be dismissive of the struggles of transgender people.

Also the word "transgender" is an adjective. To refer to a person, it is transgender person, transgender woman, etc.

Loganathan Arumugam said...

Hi, Now you can post your article in audio format at www.myaudibles.com, Send your articles in document format to www.myaudibles@gmail.com. We convert your articles in to audio format and publish it in myaudibles.com site, for free.

Let your useful articles get heard to the world.

Our Facebook page: http://www.facebook.com/MyAudibles